CONTENTS
Transitions -Diane S. Frank
Advice to New AO Officers- Gloria
Fenton
2nd Annual Transgender and Ally Symposium-
Diane
Communicating Under Stress
Partners Panel
Religion & Trans
Keynote Speech
Trans/Sex and Identity
Generations of Support- Diane
From the May Meeting -Diane
The Arts - Diane
(Just click on the title above to go directly to an article.)
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
[To
Top]
Transitions
This is the first
newsletter in quite a while, and I hope my successor while be more
regular than I’ve been recently.
My contract abroad has been renewed, and I cannot fulfill,
even to the minimal extent I have been, the duties of an AO officer,
not the least of which is attending meetings.
But a Director of Outreach and Communications needs to be out
there too, and I can’t. It’s
one heck of a commute from Europe.
I’ll be happy to show whoever takes my place the ropes and
help out behind the scenes, and I hope to contribute columns now and
then about what I observe about life abroad.
I’ve seen a few things
that I should mention… A television series in the Netherlands
about some magical MtF situation.
I can’t find any plot synopses.
The pictures I’ve seen from it shows the usual kinds of
themes, for example cluelessness about what one does with one’s
legs in short skirts. I’m
not sure whether the MtF side is played by a man or a woman… then
again you never know these days.
Then there was a personal finance article about boyfriend
jeans that had the male and female writing team switching clothes,
with pictures. Of
course, she was nonchalant about it, and he made a show of being
embarrassed. I never was
able to find a weblink to it.
This newsletter I want to
cover two serious topics. First
was the TransOhio meeting two weeks ago in Columbus, and the second
is an interview with Merâl Crane.
Merâl may be the longest practicing gender therapist in
Ohio, with a history of support and activism.
Her transition is that she’s taking a step back from some
support group functions and turning things over to the members
themselves.
My transitions are
multiple. Leaving this
task behind for someone else, further adapting to life in Europe.
But I’m only an email away.
I’ll write newsletter articles.
I’ll still be on our super exclusive super secret yahoo
group. And you can write
too. I’ll be back
sooner or later.
[To
Top]
Advice
for New AO Officers
Some Thoughts
For The New Alpha Omega Officers
Keep in mind that someone needs to be at the meeting place on meeting
days, no later than 5:30 PM. That allows time for setting up for the meeting,
but also time for people that may need time to change for a meeting. In the
olden days, someone had to be at the meeting place by 4:00 PM. Kathy and I have
been setting up meetings or helping to set up meetings for the better part of 18
years. It is now time for someone else to do it.
There are
stock supplies, such as softdrinks, water, plates, etc., that are kept at the
meeting place. Someone has to keep track of all those items, and restock the
items as needed. Kathy and I have also done that for the better part of many
years.
If there is a
theme or special decorations needed, or wanted for a meeting, then someone has
to make sure that those items are taken care of.
It is
important to try and keep a meeting on schedule, such as the meal at 7:00 PM,
and starting the meeting at 8:00 PM. That is not always easy to do.
The number of
people showing up early to help with setting up for a meeting can vary
drastically from month to month, so plan the best that you can, in case there is
not a lot of help. You will seldom
have a really good idea of how many people will attend a meeting, so it is
difficult at times to plan for how many seats to set up, or how much food to
have.
If a meeting does need to
be cancelled, someone does have to make that call, and then do their best to
contact everyone that may be attending.
Someone does need to make
sure that new people have good directions to the meeting place, and inform them
to come to the back of the building.
As much as possible someone does have to plan the main items for the meal, and
then do their best to get others to fill in around those items. Meal planning is
not always easy.
There are two keys for the meeting place, and they must be kept track of. Also
the Church must be able to get in contact with at least a couple of people, just
in case there is a question or a concern.
It is important to try and keep programs, and/or Speakers, interesting for the
group. Getting Speakers is not always easy. I wish the new officers well in this
regard.
Someone does need to be
aware of the restroom situation, as far as a CD using the Ladies Room. Out of
respect for the women of AO, we have asked CD's to use the Mens Room. This has
been an issue a few times in the past.
If the Changing Room is used, then
new people must be shown where it is, and someone must make sure that it is
cleaned up at the end of the meeting.
It must also be checked that the restrooms are clean at the end of the meeting,
and that the restroom doors are opened up before AO leaves for the night. The
Church leaves the doors open when nobody is there.
If items of the Church Kitchen are
used, then they must be cleaned and put back where they belong. These items may
include a coffee pot, plates, dishes, etc..
Items in the Church refrigerator must be kept separate from group items.
Chairs and tables must be put back as they were at the end of a meeting, so as
to not disrupt any Church services the next day. Also if needed the floor must be
vacuumed.
If the
thermostat is changed, then it must be set back to where it was.
The last person leaving the meeting
place must make sure that the lights are out, and that the door is properly
locked.
Trying to keep a
meeting running smoothly, is not always easy. Questions or concerns may come up
at a meeting, but they may not come up until long after a meeting. All Officers
must be available to the members, and prospective new members, to take care of
issues as needed.
Payments of dues, and/or meeting fees, must be collected at every meeting, even
if the Director of Finance is not there. Also the Church must get its rent
payment as well. Someone must make sure that the
web provider has a contact name, and a credit card number for their yearly
charges.
Someone must
also make sure that there is a name and address for the groups Corporation
Papers. This is required by State and Federal rulings. I have had my name on
these papers for about twelve years now, so it is time for someone else to take
over.
Keep in mind that taking care of group concerns, may very often entail doing
what is needed to create the least impact to the group.
And someone must be
willing to handle the PRAISE and/or FLACK that may happen from both within the
group, but from outside the group as well.
These are but a few little points for new Officers to be aware of, but I am sure
that you will find many more as you hold office.
As an Officer, nothing is
unimportant
Kathy and I are looking
forward to some time as just being regular members. If we can help with advice,
we will, but it is time for others now.
So, to the
Officers, all the power.
Respectfully Submitted,
Gloria Sue Fenton
an AO oldtimer
[To
Top]
Notes
from the 2nd Transgender and Ally Symposium, August
14-16, 2009
-
Diane S. Frank
At least this time there
was no snow. The LAST
time I tried to attend this there one of the worst snow storms to
hit Ohio in a long time. No
conference. Snowed in.
Not dressed up and still
nowhere to go. And then
trying to make it back afterwards.
I figured the odds of such a snowstorm in August were
substantially lower.
I also need to acknowledge
Merâl Crane’s hospitality…I stayed in her house for the two
nights I was there. If
you’re one of the devoted readers of my columns for the past 8
years, you’ll know that despite not being on a transition path,
someone I became friends with Meral and her husband.
I went to this conference,
during my brief sojourn back in the US principally to hear 3 talks
by Helen Boyd (author of “She’s Not The Man I Married” and
“My Husband Betty”). For
those short of memory, supported by funding from Margaret we hosted
Helen on a speaking tour here Memorial Day Weekend about 3 years
ago. At one of the
stops, a couple from Columbus dropped in.
So it was certainly a nice thing to have MG (as she goes by
on the internet these days) arrange for Helen to be the Keynote
speaker as well as moderate a forum for partners.
MG herself did a superb job of putting the panel together.
It’s good when partners get involved.
MG credits Helen with a lot of support helping her adapt to
her partner’s transition.
Also presenting were several old friends of mine, Kat Holtz, Joni
Christian and Mara Kiesling. Kat
led a panel discussion that I participated at UU Church in Kent some
years back. Joni is a
friend of AOs as well as mine having helped out for the Fashion show
that Pam and Sue did
with us for Weekenders™ did
back in 2003. Joni
founded the “Open Door Coffee House”, a LGBT friendly open
coffee house where you can share your talents, express yourself, or
just sip coffee, nosh and schmooze with friends or make new ones.
Mara Kiesling I met a few years back at a transfamily
function of some sort. She
is founding Director of the NCTE, a major activist organization
working for trans rights.
What
was unfortunate from my viewpoint was the complete lack of any
sessions for people who weren’t involved in a transition path.
But in a sense we have only ourselves to blame.
If we, and by we I mean trans people who are not transition
tracked, be they crossdressers, middle pathers or whatever can’t
organize and arrange their own sessions, there’s no reason to
expect others to do it for us.
So without further ado…
my notes on the session that I attended:
[To
Top]
COMMUNICATING
UNDER STRESS
Whether it’s coming out
at work or to a spouse, or negotiating whether you really need that
pair of earrings, trans
people of all stripes face the potential of many and frequent
stressful conversations. “As”,
I thought, “does just about everyone else”.
With that thought in mind, the first seminar I attended was a
communications seminar presented by
Ellen Siegel, LISW. She
quickly covered a variety of topics, and left two handouts.
A one hour workshop barely touches the surface
communications, but the outlines might help some people get started
on finding the help they need. Below
are the topics covered in each of the handouts.
They don’t line up with each other.
|
Negative and Destructive Communications
Approaches
|
Good Communications Strategies
|
|
Avoiding Conflict altogether
|
Stay focused
|
|
Being Defensive
|
Listen carefully
|
|
Over generalizing
|
Try to see their point of view
|
|
Being Right
|
Respond to criticism with empathy
|
|
Psychoanalyzing/Mind Reading
|
Own What’s yours
|
|
Forgetting to Listen
|
Use “I” messages
|
|
Playing the blame game
|
Look for compromise
|
|
Trying to “Win” the Argument
|
Take a time-out
|
|
Making Character attacks
|
Don’t Give Up
|
|
Stonewalling
|
Ask for help if you need it
|
[To
Top]
THE
PARTNER PANEL
Moderated by Helen Boyd,
five partners of transpeople including MG talked about their
experience. This panel
was somewhat atypical in that only MG didn’t know from the
beginning. All the other
partners knowingly entered into the relationship.
In leading off the
discussion, Helen made the point that while transpeople have a lot
of information available to them about various paths through the
gender jungle, partners are standing at the edge alone with a
machete. There are
no words for the identities of partners, which can be challenged by
their association with a transperson.
One of the more striking
examples of this was the experience of James, a gay man who had an
18 month relationship with an FtM.
His gay friends questioned his identity and sexuality.
Usually we hear about the female partners of MtFs dealing
with assumptions of being or becoming lesbian.
The transitioning person usually has no problem being seen as
lesbian or gay…but their partner has a huge issue to grapple with.
For some, such as Helen and MG it did free them up to explore
their own sense of gender.
Another problem is that
trans tends to take up all the air in the room.
There will always be more needs and issues in a relationship
than just ‘teh’ trans, but trans has a way of displacing
everything else. It can
often lead a partner thinking ‘there’s something wrong with
me’.
Helen introduced a new
concept into the discussion, a distinction between public and
private space. For her
and Betty, there is the public space of author and partner, which is
very gendered/sexed/sexualized and their private space where they
are just two people. In
that private space distinctions about body parts and gender roles
can disappear or at least be minimized.
Questions of sexuality lose ground to simply pleasing and
being pleased by someone you love.
I find this an easy idea to grasp, considering the
adjustments that age and illness can force on the sexuality of so
many people anyhow.
[To
Top]
GODS,
GODDESSES, ATHEISTS & JESUS: TRANSGENDER IN RELIGION
Kat Holtz, who I meet at a
trans 101 event at a UU in Kent, (see http://aosoc.org/silhouette/2007/February2007.htm#life
) presented a summary of the stances various religious groups take
towards trans. I came into the seminar late, but she seemed to have
done a pretty thorough and non-biased job, pointing out places of
difficulty and places of acceptance.
She presented a surprising amount of material on the Muslim
world.
[To
Top]
KEYNOTE
SPEECH
(read it yourself here: http://www.myhusbandbetty.com/2009/08/17/transohio-keynote-the-metamorphosis-of-us/
)
(Warning
–deals with transsexual issues)
Times
have changed. It
wasn’t that long ago that Helen wrote about Betty, her
crossdressing spouse. Now
she writes and lectures on gender theory and Betty is engaged in a
transition process, one that goes as slowly as Betty can manage and
as quickly as Helen can go, with the end objective of growing old
together and walking along the beach hand-in-hand.
When Helen started with all this, it seemed like all there was
available to partners, spouses, SO was TriEss.
That wasn’t enough, and Helen set off into that jungle with
a machete and came through the other side with a book or two and a
distinct voice for spouses.
For a while TriEss was
fairly hostile to Helen’s books.
Now, in keeping with transitions and changing times, Helen
will speak at a upcoming TriEss meeting in Chicago (Holiday Enfemme
November 4-8 http://tri-ess.org/hef/events_onsite.html
) as a keynote speaker.
Another transition that
Helen noted was a change in expectations.
Recently it seems that couples are expected to stay together
through a transition, whereas before separation and divorce were
expected. We aren’t
quite sure when “Stand by Your Man” was extended to this.
Helen and I have had subsequent correspondence about this:
One
of Helen's talks in Columbus last weekend noted that there seemed to
have been a change in expectations, that before divorce
was regarded as inevitable, while now there seems to be an
expectation that couples will stay together. I don't know that
either expectation has much justification in data....good hard data
about any of this is just about impossible to find.
The Panel that Madame George lined up had largely accepting partners
(or former partners in the one case) in it. The person who seemed to
have the most traditional view of things before was MG herself, the
rest were already well outside the normative universe. I find it
hard to imagine a spouse who was freaking out about the whole thing
accepting an invitation to be on such a panel in such a venue.
I wonder sometimes if this expectation of staying together can turn
into a sense of entitlement and blame. Certainly there's a lot of
writing that views the spouse as a obdurate obstacle at the 'why
can't I go out bowling with the guys" level. We've seen our
share of "If she really loved me, she wouldn't let my
transition change things".
I guess I'm wondering if the reason that there is this expectation
of staying together is that for the t-people involved it's useful.
Not fact based, but just useful. With the expectation of divorce,
there is a basic framework understanding that a spouse can't be
expected to put up with transition, and that 'blame' if any exists
falls on the trans person, a burden they must accept as part of
their lot. With the expectation of staying together, the burden and
blame is shifted to the spouse. The underlying assumption here
contrary to Helen's recent signature (If you've met one transperson,
you've met one transperson) is that all trans-people are about the
same... so If couple A stays together, trans person A and trans
person B are the same, then couple B not staying together must be
the fault of spouse B. This kind of blame shift happens to women a
lot. I find it repugnant...but very, very human.
Helen
responded:
diane,
YES to what you said.
i almost always have a trans person say to me, "if my wife were
like you" or "any more like you at home?" &
depending on the person, i'm either thinking "you're not Betty,
you have no idea who I am & how hard it is to live with ME"
or, in a less charitable moment, "believe me, you wouldn't get
away with half your bullshit if i was your wife."
so. yeah.
i have always agreed with the idea that trans people should expect
their relationship to break up. it's so much to handle, as a
partner, & we don't get any support from nearly anyone in our
lives, which exacerbates the problem. or, from another talk i did,
we have to do everything the transitioning person does, but
backwards & in heels.
__________________
The
rest of the talk reflected some guidelines from her own experience
and her reflections on the changes that have happened in the last 10
years. Since you can
read the original text, I’ll await your letters on what important
observations I should have mentioned.
[To
Top]
Trans/Identity
and Sex
(Warning
this really IS about sex, refers to Porn, but it isn’t the least
prurient)
The
last of Helen’s talks dealt very frankly with sexual issues
associated with crossdressing and transsexuality.
Helen’s attitude is reflected in her remark about attending
MtF conventions where no one talks about sex but (shocker!) everyone
is doing it. At FtM
conventions there’s also lots of sex going on, but surprise,
everyone talks about it. Helen
feels that talking about it is a much better idea.
One
of the concepts that gets taught in transgender 101 is that
sexuality and gender identity are separate things.
The problem is that in the post-graduate seminars things are
a bit more complicated. For
people in a relationship with someone who is trans the old rules can
(but don’t always) fall away.
Is a woman who is able to enjoy sex with a MtF person really
a lesbian? The spouse
may be very unhappy with having a lesbian identity imposed or
expected while her trans-partner is joyful about it.
Another
problem has to do with ‘who makes the first move’ and ‘who
leads the dance’. In
the heterosexual mythology there is at least lip-service paid to the
guy being in charge. Of
course you can find plenty of exceptions to that.
But the problem has as much to do with the language needed to
say describe what is going on, and that language not being available
except in the queer and kink communities.
If you get away from traditional male/female roles in the
bedroom, what do you call it? How
do you make it work? And
what happens with inequality of desire or changes in desire?
Where do you turn to for sexual role models?
Helen and Betty actually found inspiration in a particular
porn movie that gave them a way to make things work for both of
them. (No, I’m not repeating the title.
Ask me.)
I
expect there is a book coming here.
Helen has been leading workshops and lecturing on this for a
while. (Helen says no).
During
the talk 2:00 passed, which marked a national moment a same sex
kiss-in to protest attitudes towards public displays of affection in
queer couples. Since
I’m not one to kiss and tell, I won’t say which nationally known
activist I pressed lips with momentarily as gesture of solidarity.
[To
Top]
Sessions
I didn’t attend
There were 27 session
during the day, of which you could attend only five.
Session of interest that I missed were
·
Everything
you wanted to know about trans but were afraid to ask- Merâl
Crane. Meral told me
later this just turned into a Q&A, and since I was staying with
her, it seemed to me that I could skip this one, which was at the
same time as the partner panel.
·
The State
of Our Community- Mara Kiesling-
This was a goof on my part.
I had wanted to attend but the placard outside the room made
it look as if she was going to be talking exclusively about ENDA.
·
Open
Door Coffee House- Joni Christian-
While I was glad that Joni was talking, and I’ve been an
attendee and strong advocate for this organization, I simply had
another talk I wanted to hear at the same time.
Final
Notes on the Conference
The
conference was well organized and the facilities were quite
reasonable for an event of this size.
I could wish for some of the entertainment to take place
outside of the usual clubs, but whatever pays the bills.
Would I go again? Probably
not unless a speaker such as Helen were there, or if I got involved
in the development of program material for non-transitioning people,
not likely from here.
[To
Top]
Meral
Crane- Generations of Help
-
Diane
This
year marks the 30 anniversary of the Gender Program of Central Ohio.
It doesn’t mark the
beginning of therapist, counselor and professor Meral Crane’s
involvement with issues of sexuality and Gender Identity.
Growing up with a mixed religious background in Turkey she
developed an appreciation of the difficulties that minorities face
in the midst of dominant cultures.
Coming from Turkey to work in an American Friends Service
program among local populations in Appalachia and Native American
populations, Meral completed graduate work in Boston where she was
first exposed to the problems of sexual and gender minorities at the
Free Clinic of Cambridgeport. This
lead to post-graduate work at the Kinsey Institute and with Masters
& Johnson. While
Meral’s work has in my experience mostly dealt with people dealing
with transsexuality (see http://www.aosoc.org/Members/Dianes%20Stuff/August%202001%20Meral%20Crane.htm
), she has also offered help to crossdressers, couples and others.
I
took advantage of staying at her house for the 2nd Annual
TransOhio Transgender and Ally Symposium in Columbus to ask her a
few questions:
You’ve just returned from the
WPATH (World Professional Association for Transgender Health)
conference in Sweden. What
made impressions on you?
Education
is making a difference in allowing parents and society to deal with
children’s issues at a younger age.
But Scandinavia with its government funded health care is
very strict about gatekeeping. This
is the negative side of state funding of medical care.
What
difference have the years made in perceptions of CDs vs
transsexuals?
Because
CDing is more accepted there is less need now for CDs to seek the
professional help that is mandated for TS who seek to transition.
Fewer spouses are freaked out by crossdressing and fewer
people are tormented by guilt and shame.
Further, there are more opportunities to deal with these
issues by peer-to-peer connections outside the professional system.
Helen
Boyd talked about a change in expectations for people transitioning,
that couples staying together was now the expected outcome.
How do you feel about that?
As
a couple’s counselor, I see a difference between hope and
expectation. I hope that
couples will stay together. But
staying together requires a willingness to walk in the other
person’s shoes. I hope
that couples will stay together, but I do not expect it.
CDing
organizations are facing declining membership across the country and
many have disappeared in recent years.
Do you have any thought and/or recommendations?
The
internet has changed the dynamics of the situation.
Now it is possible for people to find friendship online.
Umbrella groups are going away because they are less natural in
today’s environment. Being
trans doesn’t take away all the differences that cause people to
self-affiliate.
I’ve
written about the dangers of the internet, the possibility that
people can close themselves off in bubbles of like minded people and
result the reinforcement of unrealistic expectations and
encouragement of bad behavior
Bubbles
occur because there is a need for them, and good and bad aren’t
relevant.
[To
Top]
The
Little Black Dress Show at Ursaline College-
Diane
I don’t know why I even
think about little black dresses.
By definition, anything that fits me is no longer little.
But my elderly friend wanted to go, and we hadn’t spent
time together in while, so off we went to what was the first of
three openings that night. (At
the last one I ran into my friend Bob, from Victor/Victoria
who I hadn’t seen in a few years).
The allure of the LBD
isn’t so much the dress but where you wear them.
LBDs are worn to places where you find romance, adventure,
glamour, oh, and probably lots and lots of money.
And famous people, and powerful people, interesting
people…except for that awful woman from the west side who had the
nerve show up in the same dress .
The LBD show at Ursaline
College features some 30 LBDs from a variety of periods, and from a
variety of famous designers. The
lighting of the exhibit is dim and the placards containing
information about the dresses are often on the floor, making them
hard to read. The
dresses themselves ranged from simple, clean-lined shifts to full
ball gowns. A display
case featured a variety of hats, gloves and fans that might have
been worn with the dresses. I
was especially charmed by two fans made of black-died ostrich
feathers, with genuine horn handles.
The exhibit is small, and you can take in the entire thing,
even with canapés and a little wine in less than 30 minutes.
The exhibit makes a pleasant warm up to the rest of your
evening or day. On a
personal note, I was pleased that the exhibit director remembered me
from attending a previous show with my friend
( http://aosoc.org/silhouette/2007/April2007.htm#life)
You may wish to mark your calendars for September 13th
and October 10th. On
the 13th there will be a lecture from 2-4
and on the 10th from 1:30 to 4:30 a fundraiser.
More information is available at this weblink:
http://www.ursuline.edu/news/2009-spring/lbd.php
Quoting
from the release:
Gallery
hours are Tuesday through Friday, 12-5pm and Saturday and Sunday,
1:30- 4:30 pm. Ursuline College is located at 2550 Lander Road in
Pepper Pike. The Wasmer Gallery is on the west end of the campus.
For more information, contact Gallery Director Frank Frate at
440.646.8122.
[To
Top]
From
the May Meeting
-Diane
Judith DiPerna after many
false starts finally arrived to be our long promised meeting
speaker. She lead a
discussion around the meaning of the trans in a variety of words.
It was a lively discussion, but for the life of me I can’t
remember any of the important topics at this point.
I wasn’t taking notes.
[To
Top]
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
I
thought I was going to leave the arts section blank this month, but then I
stumbled on these two gems from the August 3rd issue of the New Yorker:

It
seemed it was important to get the gender straight. Would this have been
as funny if the gag started with "I'm just a human"?
Continuing
to these modern times we have:

Well....do
you?
[To
Top]
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Group Information
The Alpha Omega Society is a non-profit social support group for heterosexual crossdressers and their wives or partners. We primarily serve Cleveland and nearby Northeast Ohio communities.
Publication Information
This newsletter is copyright 2009 by The Alpha Omega Society. All rights reserved. Articles and information contained in this newsletter may be reprinted by other non-profit crossdresser organizations with advance permission of the author and provided that proper credit is given to author and source. The opinions or statements contained in this newsletter are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Alpha Omega.
Contributions of articles are welcomed, but may be altered in the editing process, with the author’s intent retained, or may be rejected, whether solicited or not. We will exchange newsletters with any other similar group.
[To
Top]
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to know when the latest newsletter is available? Ask to be included on our confidential newsletter mailing list.
Like the content? Want to see something different?
Send your newsletter comments to:
Newsletter Editor
[To
Top]