Home Up January 2003 February 2003 March 2003 April 2003 May 2003 June 2003 July 2003 AugSept October2003

You have reached the Newsletter Archives of the Alpha Omega Society.  To browse through different years, click on button labeled "Up".  To explore our website click on the button labeled "Home".
If you want to search our website for something in particular, click right here to be taken to our search page.

La Femme Silhouette

 June 2003

 

Masthead 2003

Table of Contents

CHANGING TIMES AND CHANGING THE WORLD- Gloria

Understanding a Crossdresser- Gloria

May Minutes- Kathleen


US Supreme Court Decision- Diane
Playing Hooky
-Diane
Providing Information- Diane


Bits and Pieces- Diane

The New Girl- A Book Review by Diane


An Outreach Experience- Debbie

A Night with Dame Edna


Upcoming National Events
Upcoming Meetings
Publication Notice and Club Policies

CHANGING TIMES AND CHANGING THE WORLD

When I joined Alpha Omega, back when dinosaurs roamed the earth, there was no internet. And there weren’t a whole lot of available sources about cross dressing, and/or support groups. Libraries, for the most part, had some reference material from psychological studies, that for the most part were not kind about cross dressing, or they had some books that dealt mostly with "drag" performers and such. Some magazines would, once in a while, have an article about cross dressing; and so would some tabloids. But most of these items were there for sensationalism, and not real information.

Some television talk shows did try to do honest approaches to cross dressing, but there were far more that exploited the subject just for ratings. It is a proven fact that the ratings for several talk shows went up when the topic was anything to do with a guy in a dress for any reason.

Like it or not, adult book stores were one of the few places information about cross dressing could be gotten. At thirty-seven years old, I had never been in an adult book store. My only experience that had dealt with my trying to get help and information about my cross dressing had come from a time of seeing a therapist and a psychiatrist; and it did help me to at least get out of the deep depression I had sunk into. But medication and behavior modification didn’t help me to face my situation and live with it. So at thirty-seven, I entered an adult bookstore for the first time.

By its very nature, most magazines, etc., that had anything to do with "guys in dresses" was of a sexual nature, or related to being gay or transsexual. Some tabloids that were for Alternative Lifestyles promoted dating services or open sexual groups for "pretty boys". The only magazine I found that seemed to have anything for an average guy like me was "Ladylike". "Ladylike" at least seemed to have articles and information about cross dressing support groups that were oriented more for how I saw myself as a cross dresser. And so I found the addresses for Paradise Club and for Alpha Omega.

I remember thinking to myself that if I was really going to learn about me, that I needed to talk to others like me who had learned how to accept cross dressing in their lives. So, I wrote letters to both groups telling them my deep, dark secret, and asking for whatever help they could give me. After I mailed the letters, I got really scared. I had sent out letters telling total strangers my deepest feelings, and giving them my real name, address, and phone number. I had no femme name or post office box.

And so I waited. Two weeks later, I was almost frantic with fear, and barely able to function in my real life because of that fear, when I got my first letter from Tanya and Alpha Omega. (I never did hear from Paradise Club for whatever reason. But that became unimportant to me.) Tanya’s letter became my lifeline. I wrote back just as soon as I could. Tanya and I wrote back and forth, and began talking to each other over the phone. Tanya’s words, and the sound of her laughter over the phone, let me know that somebody – just like me – cared that I existed and needed help.

Over a couple months I began to feel a whole lot better about myself as a human being, and then I faced my group interview. Again, I was scared. But Tanya and Janet, as their male selves, gave me hope and faith that I was with friends. Letters and phone calls had helped, but being with and talking to real people like myself really made a difference.

And so, after a lot of thought, I chose my name got everything I needed ready, and was set to attend my first Alpha Omega meeting. On December 3, 1988, Gloria Sue Fenton (a nervous wreck) met the world for the first time. It really wasn’t the whole world, but it was like that to me that night. Gloria (me) became someone real, and not just some nameless entity that lived in fear with feelings of guilt for being different. Thirteen other people shared that night with me, as I was born. "Gloria" drove home that night, and once I was home, "Gloria" cried for at least an hour. The tears were of joy instead of hurt.

Every meeting after that became a time for me to grow and learn about being Gloria. In turn, as I grew as Gloria, so did Martin as the man he is. Needless to say, in the years since, I have changed as a person, and so have the times. Nowadays, the internet has become the source for most information. Someone like I was way back when, can sit in the security of their own home and, not only get pictures and information, but "chat" with others, as well. For some, I guess that seems to be enough nowadays. Cyberspace allows some to explore all kinds of information (far more than any adult book store could). And there are pictures, biographies, real stories about people, fantasy stories, and just about anything else you can think of from around the world. There are "chat" rooms, one on one communication, and even live camera video.

And all this is done over a computer keyboard and monitor. There is a sense of not only security, but also anonymity.

Cross dressing still brings high ratings to talk shows on television, but has also become more of a topic on prime time television comedy and drama programs. There have been regular characters on daytime soap operas who are cross dressers. And the movies have utilized cross dressing , also. Patrick Swayzee, Wesley Snipes, Terence Stamp, Dustin Hoffman, Robin Williams, and many others have all dressed as women on the big screen. HBO recently did a movie called "Normal" that explored a couple’s struggle when the husband decided to go through sex re-assignment surgery.

The continuum of cross dressing is more of a prime topic for most media. RuPaul became a celebrity, talk show host, and even the spokesperson for a line of cosmetics. There are more places where "cross dressing" has become more mainstream, as well, such as theatrical plays, restaurants with cross dressed waitresses, and even Willard Scott, Rudy Gulianni, and Dennis Rodman have all been seen cross dressed. Many of the "Club Kids" who frequent the night spots in the big cities cross dressed (both male and female). And today, as many of our own members will attest to, there are many places they can go to while dressed up without problems.

Yes, the world has changed a lot in the last fourteen years. Even therapists, social workers, police, psychiatrists, and other professional venues are more attuned to cross dressing as a part of the human experience. Groups like Alpha Omega are no longer one of the only ways a cross dresser can express himself. Alpha Omega, and groups like ours, can seem rather tame and old-fashioned to many because of all the cultural changes that have happened. So our perceived relevance to many, is not as important as it once was.

But I am not sure that the need for groups like Alpha Omega has really diminished. It has just changed. Alpha Omega, may not be the only way some can learn about themselves and cross dressing anymore. But our being a safe, secure, and understanding environment to meet and develop friendships for cross dressers, spouses, family and friends whose lives are affected by cross dressing is still valid. For some, the clubs, going out in public, and even "chats" on the internet, can not and do not replace the need to really talk to someone face-to-face, or share some time together. That is why groups like Alpha Omega are still needed.

As times have changed, so must we as groups so that we stay relevant, as a part of the changing culture. That is our duty, our responsibility, and our challenge. How we as a group accept that challenge, and fulfill our role as a part of the cross dressing community today, is our true test of validity, for those out there yet that need a lifeline, just as I did many years ago. We may never be a bi group, or solve all the world’s problems. But every time we touch the life of someone who enters our doors, we do have the chance to change the world just a little bit more.

Respectfully,

Gloria Sue Fenton

Return to Content

UNDERSTANDING A CROSS DRESSER

Meeting Topic for June

After the May meeting Kathy and I had the chance to watch the recent Oprah show that Debbie had recorded which had a segment about Chris Howie and her daughter. Back when I started with Alpha Omega, Chris was a member of our group. Chris was still attending our meetings a year later when Kathy joined the group, as well.

It was a few months after that when Chris spoke to the group at a meeting and told us that she would be leaving the group and continuing her transition leading to sexual re-assignment surgery. That meeting was a sad one for us all.

We understood her choice, and respected the decision she was making, but it was very difficult to say good-bye to someone we all considered a friend. I am glad to know that Chris does have some fond memories of her time with Alpha Omega, as was pointed out in Diane Frank’s newsletter article last month (May issue). Please know Chris that your friendship meant so much to all of us at Alpha Omega at the time, and that Kathy and I wish you love and happiness in your life.

This article was spurred by comments made by Oprah that triggered memories of comments made by another talk show host about sixteen years ago. That other talk show host was Sally Jesse Raphael. Sally had a program on that had three guest. One guest was a female impersonator. Another guest was a post-operative male to female transsexual. The final guest was Naomi Owens, a cross dresser, from the Chicago Tri-ESS chapter.

Sally’s telling comment came late in the show when she stated that she could understand about the female impersonator, and the transsexual, but that she just could not understand about the cross dresser. Oprah said she could understand about Chris and her other guests, but when cross dressing was mentioned, she didn’t seem to be able to understand someone who is just a cross dresser. Chris did talk about the cross dressing continuum, from fetishism to post-operative transsexuals, and did well trying to explain it.

My point is that both hosts, from sixteen years ago till today, stated right on the air that neither of them could understand a cross dresser. It does make me wonder now, thinking about both programs, about just what progress, if any, we as cross dressers have made in helping anyone to better understand us as individuals.

Now these are only some of my thoughts, so they may or may not be relevant to anyone else, but here goes. A cross dresser doesn’t have a simple or easy definition for most people to reason with and accept. A fetishist feels a mental, emotional, or even physical release from wearing an article or two of feminine attire. A female impersonator is an entertainer. A transsexual is an individual feeling they were born with the wrong body in respect to the person they are inside themselves.

I admit, these are generalized definitions, and can be more encompassing than this, but the point is most people can reason with these definitions. And if they can reason it, they can understand it. Now, try defining a cross dresser in one sentence.

Do any of these fit the bill:

  1. Someone who wears the clothing of the opposite sex
  2. A guy in a dress
  3. Someone who "dresses up" to relax tension
  4. Someone who "dresses up" just for sexual reasons
  5. Someone who "dresses up" to express a dual personality (male and female)

I am sure you have come up with some of your own definitions. Let’s face it, we have been trying for years to define and understand ourselves and others like us. Now, are any of the definitions I listed or any of your own definitions encompassing enough to define all cross dressers, or even to a finer point define why you are a cross dresser?

Most people find it much easier to understand something if they can understand why it is or exists. Someone who wears the clothing of the opposite sex doesn’t tell you why it is done. A guy in a dress doesn’t tell you why the guy wears a dress. Why does "dressing up" relax tension? Is dressing up the only way a cross dresser can relax tension? If so, then why?

If "dressing up" for sexual reasons were the criteria, then why would anyone need to take on an entire feminine persona to do it? And if someone is dressing up to express a duality of themselves, then why do they feel this duality in their lives?

Does your definition answer the question why in simple terms anyone might understand? I haven’t come across a single definition of a cross dresser yet that I believed suited me or all of us together, and could easily tell someone else why I am the way I am. Some consider cross dressing a "gift" of being able to express the masculine and feminine sides of who we are. For them I am happy. For me, the turmoil I felt in my life, and the turmoil my cross dressing caused in the life of those around me for the first 38 years of my life were no gift. Even now, I accept cross dressing as part of my life, but not a gift, or a definition of who I am.

No definition of a cross dresser I have known even starts to tell another person who or what Martin and Gloria are as human beings. Let alone why we are who we are. And to me that is why a cross dresser and cross dressing are so hard for people to define and to understand.

Nobody knows why we are this way. And, to be honest, I didn’t start to find peace in my life as Martin or as Gloria until I realized that why I am didn’t really matter, but that who I am, and what I am as a human being did. I learned that being Gloria or being Martin doesn’t have anything to do with the clothes I wear. Martin is Martin. Gloria is Gloria. In the very broadest sense of any definition, the world, or society, will call me a cross dresser, and will wonder why I am a cross dresser. I can’t answer that question for them with any definitive answer. Perhaps for Oprah or Sally, or anyone else to understand cross dressing or cross dressers, they too have to learn as I did, to see beyond the clothes and make up, and discover the human beings we are. That is what really matters anyway.

Respectfully submitted,

Gloria Sue Fenton

………………….

QUESTION OF THE MONTH

Imagine that you are sitting down at a table and opening up a dictionary and looking for the definition of a specific word. That word is CROSSDRESSER. In twenty-five words or less, what is your definition of that word that you see in the dictionary.

(Note) The June program will be a discussion of the answers to this question.

 

 

 

Return to Contents

 

What You Missed Last Meeting

This is the part of the job I love, the part that appeals to my inner sadist. Not mind you that I’m a glutton. I’m perfectly willing to share the pleasure of inflicting this pain. You can have a turn too. All you need to able to is put your fingers on the keyboard and type. So, I’m about to tell those of you who dared to miss the last meeting exactly what you missed. Oh, I know there will be wailing and gnashing of teeth. But you can be redeemed brothers and sisters. All you need to do is keep your attendance record perfect.

It was delicious after all, seeing Sheila get made up by a pro from scratch...seeing every imperfection erased and replaced, and picking up pointers along the way. Cathy did the work, while Gail, gown selector and rock chick extraordinaire narrated. Quick- what makeup do you absolutely have to have in your purse? No peeking. Time’s up: Lipstick, Liner and powder. So if your handbag is helping your chiropractor buy his second yacht, you could consider lightening the load and leaving the spackling trowel and cement mixer at home.

What kind of brushes are the only ones to buy? Sable hair. How should your eyebrow color relate to your hair color? 3-4 shades darker. How are you doing so far? How about eye-liner color? 3-4 shades darker than the eyes. Where do you put blush? These days don’t put dark blush on the apple of the check- that’s reserved for a light/shiny blush. The dark blush goes under the apple, that way it makes your cheeks look thinner. How do you get that last bit of mascara out of the vial? Don’t pump in and out...that just introduces air and bacteria into something going onto your eyes. Wiggle with bottle up and down, bending the wand is safer and effective. Having trouble with clumping mascara? Try holding the brush vertically instead of horizontally.

And suppose you want to really nice arched eyebrows, but your day job requires big fuzzy caterpillars over each eye. What can you do? First you soap your eyebrows really well, and then paint liquid latex from a costume shop over them. Buy some crepe hair and you can build the eyelashes of your dreams while not sacrificing any caterpillars on the altar of beauty. That is, unless you didn’t soap them really, really well. In that case, our prayers are with you.

Perhaps the most fascinating part of the demonstration was changing the shape of Sheila’s face via surgical tape. Call it face-lift without the surgeon. You need the right type of tape, and some practice doing it. And a wig cap. The tape goes over the top of the wig cap. You can raise your eyebrows, flatten your cheeks, and tighten up your jowls and minimize your double chin Carefully pressed in place before foundation, you take years off of your apparent age. Just remember, we’re not responsible for the consequences if this micro face lift either turns you into a hottie or the Dutchess of Malfi.

As the grand finale, Cathy showed how a little hair spray (wouldn’t you know, Hairspray took home 8 Tonys) and some rubber bands turns Sheila’s hair from merely great into a spectacular architectural triumph on the scale of the hanging gardens of Babylon, or the pyramids of Egypt.

Thanks again to Cathy of Calujo’s Beauty Salon and Gail of Images Bridal in North Royalton:

12778 State Road

North Royalton, Ohio

Cathy: 440-582-5299.

Gail: 440-237-1965

Return to Contents

ALPHA OMEGA SOCIETY MEETING MINUTES

MAY 10, 2003

The meeting was called to order at 8:00 p.m. by Chairperson, Gloria Fenton. Our speakers for the evening, Gail and Kathy, were introduced. The latest version of the Vision statement was read. Kathleen made a motion to accept, seconded by Sheila. By vote, the statement was accepted. We are holding on the pledge due to the absence of our Membership Chairperson. Work is continuing on the mission statement and the constitution. When these are in place, we will then work on 501C status.

The treasurer’s report by Diane Brennan stated that we have $659.00 in our treasury including membership dues. One unexpected major expense that had to be paid was $200 for liability insurance for the year 2001. The insurance agent had covered the policy for 2001 but never received payment. This fact was discovered when Diane was attempting to get quotes for current coverage. Quotes so far have been in the $500 range.

Gloria reminded the group that anyone is welcome to join any of the committees that were set up last month. Meeting place was a topic of discussion. Some members are unhappy with our current meeting place due to lack of space and air conditioning. Our current place is $125 per month, opposed to our former meeting place at $200 per month. Options: (1) find a different meeting place. The is a location available on the west side of Cleveland which was free to the previous group. This group has moved on, so a space could be available. Our meeting night would have to change to the fourth Saturday. Pros are that it has air conditioning, more room, and could be free. Cons are that there is adjacent parking with the building on the street, people would have to walk from the parking lot to the building in a public setting, it is exposed, people can and do walk in off the street, it is less secure, there is no changing place. There is a meeting hall upstairs and a small meeting place downstairs with a kitchen. (2) Move back to our former meeting place. It would cost $200 per month, so we could have to ask attending members to kick in enough extra to meet the fee in month’s where our attendance does not cover the expense. (3) Have our group purchase an air conditioning unit for the house and see if we could get a break on the rent. It was decided that a group should get together to see scout out the location on the west side of Cleveland. Diane Brennan will talk with Nicole about the air conditioning scenario.

Other discussion: Diane Frank was contacted through our web site to read and critique "The New Girl". This is a book about a man who lived as a woman for six weeks. (See page 8) Debra Lee brought a disc of the recent Oprah Winfrey show which featured a discussion on transsexuals. One of the guests was a former member, Chris whose daughter, Noelle has written a book about her father. Deb also shared with us her experience of being part of a presentation to a CSU class with Suzie Davis on transgendered individuals. Diane Frank asked Deb if she would contribute an article for the newsletter based on this experience. (See page 9)

The menu for June will be: cold cut tray – Kathleen and Gloria; potato salad and snacks – Sheila; bread – Penny; ice cream – Diane Frank.

The topic of discussion for June will be The Question of the Month.

Gloria and Kathleen announced the date of their cook out as Sunday, August 17. It is open to our members and to invited guests.

Kathleen moved we adjourn, Mary Lee seconded. The meeting was adjourned.

Respectfully Submitted,

Kathleen Fenton, Chairperson for Member Support


Return to Contents

Who We Serve-Diane Frank

Two weeks ago I attended a Grey Pride meeting. My friend Carol from the Akron area was going to be reading from her remembrances. She wanted at least one familiar face in the audience. Earlier, she had shared some information about her partner’s late son, J. J was severely crippled from a congenital spinal disease and also it turned out he was a crossdresser. I had hoped that more information about the son would turn up in an oral presentation and I could get a fuller sense of who he was, more material to make a story out of. I was left with a simple picture of a loving non-traditional family, the son accepting his mother as a lesbian, she accepting him as a CD and the two of them having a contest to locate information about crossdressing on the internet.

For a while I was frustrated at not having a better story to share. But something more came out of this as I’ve thought about it. J. was closeted. He didn’t dress outside the house. He never shaved his beard, and by our rules of presenting as either one sex or the other, he would not have been welcomed at an Alpha Omega meeting, or just about any other organization I know of. I don’t know if his crossdressing was simply a sexual expression, as it is for many, or whether it represented something about his sense of alignment with the notions of man and woman, or was simply a form of relaxation.

J. represents the vast majority of crossdressers. For every person like me, who struggles with living a double life, there are many, many people who in ways have no life at all. Because they haven’t or can’t come to terms with their experience and feelings about crossdressing, they also don’t resolve what they feel about their ordinary life as a man. They are the ones whose sense of themselves as a man is diminished. There is one life they can’t have, and one they aren’t happy with. Not much of a life. Where is the hope?

The clue was in J’s search of the internet. Our website, our newsletter is a lifeline for people like J. These functions of Alpha Omega give people who aren’t members and indeed will never likely be members some idea of what it might be like to find what they seek. Ever time one of us writes about our experiences, whether it be coming out to one’s family, how one started, getting help with the basics, our connections with other people, we provide hope and the chance for growth to people who can’t or won’t come to our meetings. Not just people in North East Ohio, but anywhere in the world. When you write for our newsletter to share your experience and ideas, you are doing a good deed. I want to express my gratitude to Abigail and Sheila especially, who as new members have contributed material so soon after joining, and to Gloria for being unstinting in sharing of her life with us, and Kathleen for so often taking the time to give us a spouses perspective. And I want to thank Carol, whose simple story of acceptance and love in a non-traditional family helped remind me again of why what we do here is valuable.

 

Return to Contents

Bits and Pieces- Diane Frank

Ohio ENDA Information Posted

Two months, Debbie, Laura and I attended a meeting of the Cleveland Stonewall Democrats, at which a presentation was made about legislation to be proposed to the State of Ohio by State Senator Dan Brady (D). State Representative Dale Miller (D) has also proposed similar legislation. At the time we felt we had helped the cause of making transgender issues part of the discussion. Recently, a web site http://www.capitolsquarehrc.com/default.htm has gone live which provides information on the status of the legislation. Thus far seven State Senators have endorsed the bill. I regret to report that the employment issues that our community is most concerned about, being fired for legal off the job behavior does not appear to be covered...if the Bills are accurately described by the website. We will be looking into the more in the months ahead.

Gray Pride

Both Akron and Cleveland have gray pride groups for LGBT seniors (50+). The Cleveland Group meets on the second Wednesday of the month (excepting this June, 2003) and is in potluck format with categories assigned by last name. There is a featured speaker and as befitting a seniors group the evening starts and ends early. I attended to listen to my friend Carol reminisce about her long life as a lesbian, physical therapist and Peace Corps volunteer.

Gray Pride

Lakewood Senior Center West,
16024 Madison Avenue in Lakewood.
Doors open at 5:45 pm.
Food is served about 6:10.
Speaker 6:45.

See also http://www.ptcleveland.org/ For schedule and more information

Akron Pride Center: Open Door Coffee House

The Akron Pride Center, in association with the First Grace United Church of Christ holds a coffee house on the 3rd Sunday of the Month. This politics free, alcohol free gathering features the talents of members of the Church and the Akron Pride communities. Refreshments are provided by Angel Falls Coffee Company of Highland Square. I visited during May, and promptly was enrolled to sing in June by our friend Susan from Susan's Fashions (our April meeting guest). If only I can find the right gown. Anyhow, I advise getting there early as the house is packed, the refreshments plentiful and delicious. You will be entertained as well by a variety of music, comedy and poetry.

First Grace United Church of Christ is located at 350 South Portage Path (at Exchange Street, next to the Women’s City Club and in front of Coach House Theater.) There is plenty of free parking in a well-lit lot. The next meeting will be Sunday, June 15th from 6:30-9:30 PM.

The Bindlestiff Family Circus at the Beachland Ballroom.

How could I pass it up? A show called "High Heels and Red Noses" and an offer of $2 off the admission price if one came in costume. I was so looking forward to looking down my nose at the ticket seller and saying sweetly, with only a touch of asperity, "Costume? What costume?!". But the ticket seller didn’t offer. Sometimes you have a win-win situation.

Beachland Ballroom is the second underground cultural treasure in Cleveland, joining the Cleveland Public Theatre as a local haven for the avante garde and just plain weird. Keeping Cleveland balanced, if in an off-balance sort of way, Beachland Ballroom is located on the East Side, while CPT is on the West Side. It can be a little tricky to get to, especially from the East Suburbs. The best access from either the east or west is off of route 90, something that can be frustrating to people who live, as I do about due south of the place.

Beachland Ballroom
15711 Waterloo Rd.
Cleveland, Ohio 44110

tel: 216.383.1124

http://www.beachlandballroom.com/

But while the ghosts of the old vaudeville and burlesque shows are probably tickled pink at the presentations at CPT, I suspect the old Croatians whose "Liberty Home" was converted to the Beachland Ballroom in 2000 are probably spinning in their graves. This rapid rotation occurring despite BB’s nod to ethnic music from Eastern European groups such as Harmonia.

Look over the concerts, pick a group that seems weird enough and it’s most likely a safe place to go. I certainly had no hassles, and just to prove how small a place Cleveland is, I ran into Mary & Mary, a couple I know from other theatrical venues, most recently the Wild Plum Theatre, where one of the Marys performed and the other graciously offered me a saved seat ( see Newsletter, April 2003).

When am I going to describe the circus you ask? Is now soon enough? Yup there were high heels galore on the fetching and provocative female performers. The were rubber noses all around. And a subversive post 911 political edge that had the first act finale performed in gas masks.


The Bindlestiff’s show is a collection of old routines that you probably haven’t seen since you were a kid watching Captain Kangaroo, plus some now politically incorrect staples, such as the sad drunken hobo that used to be a common act. You have your sword swallower, you have your aerial act (a striptease on a trapeze), you have your clowns throwing Indian Clubs, and clowns performing the cigar box balancing tricks, a markwomanship whip act, hula hoops by the dozens, and two male clowns playing around with burlesque routines, including pasties. One line said by the lead clown Mr. Pennygaff (the Emmett Kelly like hobo, and later Jack Nicholson impressionist) could apply to the entire cast- "a $100,000 liberal arts education and THIS is what I do for a living". Given the reasonable ticket prices, and the entertaining use and reframing of time tested routines, he may have a chance of paying off those student loans.....someday.

For More Information about the Bindlestiff Family Circus see:

http://www.bindlestiff.org/cirkus.html

 

 


Return to Contents

 

"The New Girl" by Mike Reynolds Reviewed by Diane Frank

Reviewing this book has been difficult, as I’ve had to fight "knowing" what I was going to write about it before I’d read it, the entire way through the book. The premise of the book is engaging for Alpha Omega members. A man tries living and working as a woman for six weeks to understand the difference in the sexes. He is motivated in part by a woman’s simple declaration, "You can’t understand me!" He comes back from the experience changed or not. I remember back when I was in graduate school wanting to live as a woman for 6 months. Back when I was younger, thinner, and yes, prettier. Sort of a junior semester abroad. But resources and will were lacking, so looking over Mr. Reynolds’s shoulder as he undertook this project became very interesting.

After over a year of preparation starting with creating a back history, a resume, buying a wardrobe, taking herbal treatments to emulate estrogen effects, having laser hair removal for his beard and mustache, even getting a driver’s license, Mr. Reynolds becomes Lisa Anne Weber, an out of work writer/PR woman, searching for job in the New Haven, CT area. Lisa has many deficits as a woman, being 6’1" (oh how I sympathize), overweight, broad shouldered, big nosed and needing a wig. Lisa keeps a daily diary, noting her wardrobe, the weather, her job hunting and social activities, her interactions with all she encountered and her feelings about those interactions. Quite a lot to do.

This book attempts a very important purpose. I’ve noted in another article how vital to many people what we write in our newsletter and post on our website is. So many people in our communities wonder about what it would really be like to be a woman or just to step outside. Mr. Reynold’s book is an important addition to seeing things from another point of view. There are so many illusions that Mr. Reynold’s book dispels and much that I agree with based on my own experiences; how women are treated, passing as a transsexual rather than as a woman, how women relate to each other, being a woman in public space. Most of all I appreciated the sense of bonding with women as a woman, and the alienation, the loss, the impossibility of doing that as a man. What Mr. Reynolds describes is vastly, and to this reviewer refreshingly different from writings about time spent at CD outings such as Holiday En Femme or the Lake Erie Gala (for something closer to home). Perhaps, then, with these positive remarks in mind you should stop reading and buy a copy of the book and read it. Or read this recently published interview and review in the New Haven Register: http://www.zwire.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=8253379&BRD=1281&PAG=461&dept_id=517539&rfi=6.

After you’ve read it the rest of my comments might be more useful. But for those of you curious enough to read on:

I put the book down for a while, hoping that the passage of time would lessen my concerns, but found, alas that they remain. What concerns me is what is missing from the book, the feeling that important parts of the story are being left out, and the feeling that the author had and has no sense of connection with any thing anyone else has written in the area, or well known conflicts.

One of the seminal books of the civil rights era was a book called "Black Like Me". John Howard Griffin undertook UV and chemical treatments to make his skin dark enough for him to pass as black, and then wrote about what it was like to be treated as black in the segregationist south. He died of skin cancer that resulted from his experiment in racism in 1980. For more information about Mr. Griffin and his work see: http://www.tsha.utexas.edu/handbook/online/articles/view/GG/fgr99.html,

and http://www.angelfire.com/or/sociologyshop/BLM.html#blm2

In many ways Black Like Me is the unacknowledged predecessor in style to "The New Girl". "Black Like Me" raised important questions about racism in American Society and the role people played in maintaining that institution. I found it disappointing that Mr. Reynolds didn’t frame his task in this context, and take cues from the questions asked and answered. For example, as southern white men maintained racism, how do men maintain sexism? It’s not that he doesn’t observe it happening to him, but he doesn’t chose to see it as a system or it seems reflect on his own actions as a man as a part of that system. Even rejection of the notion of sexism as a system would be preferable to not addressing the question at all.

Another problem I noticed is that while his motivation is claimed to be to investigate the statement "you just don’t understand me!" Mr. Reynolds calls himself a transgender activist. Some of his activities during his 6 weeks as a woman were involved in gathering material for profiles of transgendered people. There is no clear statement about how Mr. Reynold’s interest in transgender issues came about. There is no reference to any work by Mr. Reynolds being published or in preparation. What is a straight person, with no interest in crossdressing per se, no claim of alienation from his expected gender role doing being a transgender activist? What forms has his activism taken? We aren’t told.

As Lisa Weber, Mr. Reynolds enrolls in a women’s empowerment workshop. He is later challenged as being a man. He does not ‘fess up’, but continues the charade. The next day he gets a phone call from the police department telling him to stay away from the women’s center and that group. I found Mr. Reynold’s account of this episode and his insisting that he himself was a victim of sexism less than satisfactory.

Apparently Mr. Reynolds was unaware of the problems a post-op transsexual, Kimberly Nixon faced attempting to become a counselor at a rape crisis center in Vancouver, Canada and the context his actions might be seen in. While a Canadian civil rights panel headed by a woman eventually backed Ms. Nixon’s claims for damages, there was a strong case made for women being able to define their own safe space as they see fit. Mr. Reynolds could not insist, as Ms. Nixon could, that as a post-op transsexual she was legally a woman. Mr. Reynold’s identification was fraudulent. My reading of the final, hostile encounter was a woman sensing a man invading her space, intuitively knowing she’s being lied to, and acting on that intuition even if she can’t prove a thing at the time. We readers know she’s right. Mr. Reynolds seems unable to put himself in her shoes, despite his own experiences in how women are treated by men. This section is a major disappointment in the book, making Mr. Reynold’s quest look less genuine and more self-indulgent.

The last unanswered questions raised by the book have to do with relationships. We know that Mr. Reynolds now feels cut off from the ability to bond with women, once he presents as a man again. And we know that the whole experiment created a strain in his relationship with his girlfriend. What happens to that relationship? The book doesn’t tell us, but we do learn from the New Haven Register article that they will soon be wed. Does what he learned during his 6 weeks as a woman have any effect on this relationship? What does his girlfriend say about his experience, what he has taken home? As a teacher, does Mr. Reynolds now relate to his female students any differently that before? It seems somewhat perverse that he keeps score about one thing that happened in business, noting that 85% of his sales come from women while not articulating the effects on deeper and more durable bonds.

While the desirable experiences of bonding with women were demonstrated to be reproducible even a year later, I can’t help feeling that the author ended where he started, with a list of women’s issues, some intellectual understanding of them, but not much sunk into the gut. So while I’m glad that someone has attempted this book and this experience, and I recommend the book, I also wish for more than what the book delivered.

My partner also read the book and similar reactions except for a few:

  1. She thinks I'm being a bit hard-nosed about relating "The New Girl" to "Black Like Me", especially in terms of sexual politics. 
  2. She does like the sections about bonding with women, but felt the emphasis on clothing was too typical of crossdressers. I disagreed with this point, saying that from my perspective, the clothing was simply a constant problem of insecurity about wearing the right outfit for the exact circumstances, without years of experience to fall back on.

We both recommend the book. The strengths of the book lie in the details of the experiences and the emphasis on the role other women have in women’s lives are what matter most. Those are things rare and precious when compared to most other offerings.

 

 

 

 

Return to Contents

An Outreach Experience

By Deborah Benton

It is one thing to sit back and listen to people talking and writing about outreach and how important it is to perform this duty. The duty of educating those who are not affected by crossdressing or transgendered issues, falls upon us who are.

I was one of those who sat back and thought how noble this effort is, or would be in my case.

I have to be honest and say I have done little to further the outreach necessary to make an impact on our society.

I am not saying that I have been sitting on the sidelines, letting life just pass me by. I believe I am living proof that what I believe in I am living. But this is a passive experience. I have no choice. Those in my sphere of influence have gained an experience of being force-fed outreach.

Have I paid my dues? Not by a long shot. Opportunities do arise.

I read in the calendar section of the Gay People’s Chronicle where a transgender panel discussion was scheduled at Cleveland State University. I thought to myself, well I might as well go and have an experience. On the day of the panel discussion, I left work and thought I would grab a bite to eat and then attend the panel discussion. I left work later than I had planned, so I chose to go directly to the college and wait out the time before the discussion. I went to the building that the panel would be held in and found the classroom empty. I did some reading and then I noticed some students entering the room. I decided to join them and see what was going on. A couple of women were sitting in the classroom so I sat among them and gradually worked my way into the conversation. Most of it was day-to day, matter-of fact conversation, nothing to reveal what was about to happen.

After a short while a face I was familiar with walked in. It was Sue from Akron, who was a former Alpha Omega member. She radiated warmth and confidence and as she noticed me sitting there, she lit up even more. The class professor rolled his way in, being wheelchair bound, and I started to surmise that this was not simply a panel discussion, but was an actual class. News to me. Nothing was said in the "Chronicle" about a psychology class, let alone a class on abnormal psychology.

Would I have shown up had I known this fact? Maybe not. I do not believe the subject of transgendered behavior warrants it.

Next installment next month.

Return to Contents

This Just In:

A NIGHT WITH DAME EDNA
February 17-29, 2004
Palace Theatre

Dame Edna, simply the most talented and adored Australian to grace the stage, has returned to her beloved United States for another fun-filled theatrical tour. With Special Tony Award in hand, Dame Edna, is back with the funniest show you will ever see, and she will guarantee you at least one major laugh per half-minute!!! A Night with Dame Edna opened in Miami, Florida, in September 2002, and American audiences have been hysterical with laughter ever since! Barry Humphries stars as the world's funniest diva!

www.dame-edna.com

Return to Contents

 

Upcoming National Events

A YANKEE DOODLE OF A SPICE, July 9-13,2003

Windsor Locks, CT

www.tri-ess.org/spice

HOLIDAY EN FEMME, November 6-9, 2003

Denver, CO

www.Holiday-EnFemme.org

www.rmtsk.org/holiday

COLORADO GOLD RUSH, March 6-9, 2003

Denver, CO

www.ColoGoldRush.org

Lake Erie Gala

November 20-22, 2003

Erie, PA

www.eriesisters.org.

 

Return to Contents

 

Publication Notice and Club Policies

 

This newsletter is copyright 1998-2003 by The Alpha Omega Society. All right reserved. Articles and information contained in this newsletter may NOT be without advance permission from the individual author. Write to editor@aosoc.org in order to contact the author. When permission is granted, a copy of the issue containing the reprinted material must be sent to Alpha Omega within two months after the material is published and proper credit is given to author and source.

The opinions or statements contained in this newsletter are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Alpha Omega. Contributions of articles are welcomed, but may be altered in the editing process, with the author’s intent retained, or may be rejected, whether solicited or not. Absolutely no sexually explicit material may be accepted or printed.

Alpha Omega is a non-profit social support group for heterosexual crossdressers and their wives or partners. Also, members from related organizations, helping professionals, and approved guests are welcome when cleared through Alpha Omega’s officers.

Meetings are the second Saturday evening of each month unless a special event is scheduled that takes the place of the regularly scheduled meeting. The location of the meeting or event is only released to members or others with the approval of an officer. Members and visitors must be 18 years of age or older. We will exchange newsletters with any other similar group. Send all correspondence to Alpha Omega, P.O. Box 2053, Sheffield Lake, OH 44054.

Return to Contents